FAMILY-OWNED SINCE 1985
Michaels Jewelers: A Family Legacy of Celebrating Your Milestones
For nearly four decades, the Michaels family has dedicated itself to marking life’s most significant moments with exceptional jewelry. Founded in 1985, our name has become synonymous with the trust and personal attention that only a family-run business can provide. We believe every milestone-from a first anniversary to a graduation gift-deserves a piece that carries as much meaning as the occasion itself, crafted…
Year Founded
Years of Family Stewardship
Generations of Leadership
THE MICHAELS STANDARD
How Our Experts Curate for Meaning
Every piece in our collection earns its place through a deliberate process. We don’t chase trends; we seek out jewelry that resonates, partnering with designers whose vision aligns with moments worth marking.
Vetted Designer Portfolio
We represent fewer than forty independent and atelier designers, each chosen for distinct craftsmanship and ethical sourcing. This selectivity means every necklace, ring, or bracelet comes with a provenance we can personally verify.
Beyond the 4Cs Grading
Our gemologists evaluate stones using GIA or AGS certification as a baseline, then assess brilliance, fire, and scintillation by hand. This dual-layer process ensures a diamond’s character, not just its certificate, guides our recommendation.
Milestone-First Curation
We organize collections by the emotion they commemorate-a 25th-iversary band, a graduation pendant-rather than by price tier. This approach lets you find the piece that fits the occasion before you consider the budget.
Limited-Batch Exclusives
Many of our featured designers produce runs of 50 to 200 pieces per style. We secure allocations early, offering you jewelry that remains uncommon even in a major city like Chicago or Dallas.
From Ethical Mine to Your Moment
Every gemstone at Michaels Jewelers begins its journey in a specific place-sourced from trusted mining partners in Botswana, Sri Lanka, and Zambia. Our TraceSource program tracks each stone from its country of origin to our showcase, ensuring transparent, responsible sourcing for the jewelry that marks your most significant occasions.
Botswana Diamond Solitaire Pendant
Crafted with a single, ethically sourced diamond from Botswana, this pendant offers timeless clarity and a documented origin story through our TraceSource program.
Sri Lankan Sapphire Halo Ring
Features a vibrant, untreated blue sapphire from Sri Lanka, encircled by a halo of diamonds for a piece that blends rare color with verifiable provenance.
Zambian Emerald Stud Earrings
Deep green emeralds, responsibly mined in Zambia, are set in classic four-prong settings for a pair that brings rich, natural color to any occasion.
Ruby & Diamond Tennis Bracelet
Alternating rubies and diamonds create a striking pattern, with each ruby traced to its mine of origin in Mozambique for complete supply chain clarity.
Botswana Diamond Three-Stone Ring
Representing past, present, and future, this ring features three graduated diamonds sourced from Botswana, each verified under the TraceSource program.
ANNIVERSARY COLLECTION HIGHLIGHT
Decade Diamond Anniversary Band
★ 4.9 · 127 reviews
Ten years together deserve a ring that honors every shared laugh, every quiet morning, every challenge overcome side by side. The Decade Diamond Anniversary Band from Michaels Jewelers captures a decade of partnership in a single, luminous circle. Each of the channel-set round brilliant diamonds-totaling 1.25 carats-represents one year of your journey, precision-set into a 14K white gold band that sits flush…
- 1.25 total carat weight of round brilliant diamonds, channel-set for a smooth, snag-free profile
- Available in 14K white gold, yellow gold, or rose gold to match any existing bridal set
- Graduated diamond sizing creates a subtle tapered effect from center to edges
- Designed to sit flush against most standard wedding bands without gaps
- Each stone is hand-selected for consistent color (G-H) and clarity (VS2-SI1)
ENGAGEMENT RING BUYING TIPS
Five Things to Know Before You Propose
An engagement ring is a deeply personal purchase and a significant financial decision. At Michaels Jewelers, we believe informed buyers make confident choices. This guide cuts through the noise to give you the practical knowledge you need, from understanding diamond grading to setting a realistic budget that feels right for you.
The cut grade is the single most important factor in a diamond’s beauty. It dictates how well the stone interacts with light, creating the sparkle and fire that makes a diamond stunning. Prioritize an Excellent or Very Good cut grade above size.
Color is graded on a scale from D (colorless) to Z (noticeable color). For most settings in white gold or platinum, a G or H color diamond appears perfectly white to the naked eye, offering excellent value.
Clarity grades the presence of tiny natural imperfections. Most inclusions in VS2 or SI1 diamonds are invisible without magnification. Choosing an ‘eye-clean’ stone at these grades lets you allocate more budget to cut and carat.
Carat measures weight, not diameter. Prices jump at key thresholds like 0.50, 1.00, and 1.50 carats. A 0.97-carat diamond can look nearly identical to a 1.01-carat but often costs significantly less.
The ring’s metal-platinum, white gold, yellow gold, or rose gold-affects color, durability, and price. Platinum is the most durable and hypoallergenic but also the most expensive. White gold offers a similar look for less.
The setting style (solitaire, halo, three-stone, pavé) frames the center stone and defines the ring’s overall character. A simple solitaire focuses all attention on the diamond, while a halo setting makes the center stone appear larger.
VERIFIED BUYER SENTIMENT
What 1,247 Customer Stories Reveal About Shopping at Michaels Jewelers
“Michaels Jewelers earns consistently high marks for attentive, knowledgeable service that makes customers feel confident in their purchase – especially during emotionally significant moments like engagements and weddings.”
★ Highlights
- Staff provide patient, informed guidance without high-pressure sales tactics
- Wide selection of certified diamond and gemstone settings across price points
- Customers feel personally attended to, even during busy weekend hours
- Consistent quality reported across different jewelry categories and materials
⚠ What to watch
- Custom design turnaround can extend beyond the initially quoted timeline
- Peak-season appointment availability is limited, sometimes requiring a two-week wait
Your Top Questions About Certifications, Answered
A GIA (Gemological Institute of America) certification is an independent laboratory report that grades a diamond’s cut, color, clarity, and carat weight with scientific precision. At Michaels Jewelers, we present this documentation for every diamond so you can make a confident, informed choice based on universally respected standards rather than sales descriptions alone.
We offer a 30-day return window on all certified jewelry. Items must be in original, unworn condition with all accompanying documentation, including the grading report and original packaging. Refunds are processed to the original payment method within 5-7 business days of receiving the return.
Michaels Jewelers provides a limited manufacturer’s warranty covering structural defects in the setting for one year from the date of purchase. The gemstone certification itself is a permanent record issued by the grading laboratory; it does not expire and remains valid for insurance or resale purposes.
Every center stone over 0.5 carats at Michaels Jewelers ships with a grading report from a recognized lab-most commonly GIA for diamonds, or the American Gem Society (AGS) for certain fancy shapes. You can cross-reference the report number directly on the issuing lab’s website to confirm authenticity before you purchase.
Yes. Lab-grown diamonds sold through Michaels Jewelers receive grading reports from the same independent laboratories-such as GIA or IGI (International Gemological Institute)-that certify natural stones. The report uses identical criteria for cut, color, clarity, and carat, clearly noting the stone’s lab-grown origin.
We recommend a professional inspection every 12 months to check prong integrity, stone security, and metal wear. Regular servicing helps preserve both the beauty and the insured value of your piece-think of it like a routine tune-up that keeps the certification-worthy quality intact.
THE MICHAELS PROMISE
Your Jewelry Grows with Your Story
Every piece from Michaels Jewelers is backed by commitments designed to protect your investment and ensure your complete confidence, from the moment of purchase through every chapter that follows.
Years in Business
Client Satisfaction Rate
Pieces Warrantied
Connecticut Locations